Testimonials & Reviews


Struan Coleman, MD, PhD

Orthopedic Surgeon located in New York, NY & Locust Valley, NY

5/5 Star Rating
15 total reviews

Struan Coleman, MD, PhD always appreciates feedback from our valued patients. To date, we’re thrilled to have collected 15 reviews with an average rating of 5 out of 5 stars. Please read what others are saying about Struan Coleman, MD, PhD below, and as always, we would love to collect your feedback.

Colton T.
5/5 Star Rating
Submitted 02/28/23
I’ve been fortunate enough to be under the care of Dr. Coleman for half a decade now. He is a true professional and as personable as they come. With Dr. Coleman’s diligent work I’ve been able to return to sport after three different shoulder surgeries. I will be forever grateful for Dr. Coleman.
Brian R L.
5/5 Star Rating
Submitted 06/19/21
Dr. Coleman helped me recover from a shoulder dislocation about fifteen years ago. I had been a gymnast in school and liked to do pull-ups and handstands before my accident. I still remember Dr. Coleman’s kind and expert care and how he helped me eventually make a full recovery.
Jacob P.
5/5 Star Rating
Submitted 03/30/21
Dr. Coleman operated on my hip over five years ago to resolve my FAI and he and his entire office were outstanding. When I hurt my shoulder in 2019 I knew I had to return to his office for help. After physical therapy didn't work he operated on my shoulder to fix a labral tear and once again everything went amazingly. You can't make a better choice than going to see Dr. Coleman.
Matt F.
5/5 Star Rating
Submitted 11/23/20
Everyone was great - from doctors to therapists upstairs. Fantastic experience!
James C.
5/5 Star Rating
Submitted 12/13/19
I saw three surgeons about my bi-lateral knee replacement. I wanted to do both at the same time as I didn't want to devote most of next year recovering from having my knees replaced. Two of the surgeons I saw said they would only do one at a time because there was a small chance that something could go wrong. I saw Dr. Coleman, who took in the entirety of who I am said, "We should do both at once because you're in good shape for your age, and the possibility of something going wrong is minor - you need to get back to living your life without pain as soon as possible." I had the surgery three weeks ago, it still hurts, but at home, I'm getting around without a cane. Dr. Coleman is great. You need a doctor who looks at you, not just figures on a chart.
Fernando L.
5/5 Star Rating
Submitted 11/03/19
Great service very professional Dr.Coleman
Mary C.
5/5 Star Rating
Submitted 10/25/19
My appointment reflected the finest professional service imaginable.
Shannondoah S.
5/5 Star Rating
Submitted 10/25/19
Best Doctors In The World. Greatest Staff!!! A Joy To Come To This Office. I was treated like Royalty !!!!
Sarah J.
5/5 Star Rating
Submitted 09/20/19
Everyone in the office was extremely helpful and friendly. Dr. Coleman was very thorough in his explanation of what I was experiencing. This is definitely the place to go.
Garry M.
5/5 Star Rating
Submitted 09/19/19
Nice new offices. Dr Coleman listened to my issue and gave me helpful advice.
Alexander S.
5/5 Star Rating
Submitted 09/17/19
Unbelievable new facility. Dr. Coleman is the best
Gary N.
5/5 Star Rating
Submitted 09/14/19
I left my appointment feeling that I was being treated by the best. Dr. Coleman exudes confidence and instills confidence which is important going into knee replacement. I respect the honest, straight forward approach and it really seems that he wants to be sure you understand what is going to happen
Lucette R.
5/5 Star Rating
Submitted 09/14/19
I felt that finally a doctor was able go hear me and to identify where my problem stemmed from and how we could try to find a path for no more pain!
Cornelius C.
5/5 Star Rating
Submitted 09/13/19
Struan was very professional and supportive throughout the pre surgery and surgery process. He helped me understand what to expect and what was going to be done. Super job!!!
Nancy M G.
5/5 Star Rating
Submitted 09/04/19
Dr. Coleman has been nothing but the best in the years I've been seeing him for my recurring hip issues--I trust him completely in his assessments and treatments. My two surgeries with him were a breeze and I wouldn't hesitate to send anyone with hip problems to his office. Until the point my hips need total replacement, he'll be my go-to hip surgeon. Cannot rate him highly enough!


We accept Blue Cross Blue Shield PPO and EPO plans. In the event that you do not have insurance or we do not take your current insurance, we will be happy to work with you. Our office can also assist with out of network claims. Please contact our office if you do not see yours listed or have any other questions.

Blue Cross Blue Shield
Our Locations

Choose your preferred location